Advanced Search

Journal Navigation

Journal Home

Subscriptions

Archive

Contact Us

Table of Contents

Sign In to gain access to subscriptions and/or personal tools.
History of Psychiatry
This Article
Right arrow Abstract Freely available
Right arrow Free Full Text (Free PDF) Free
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Right arrow Citation Map
Services
Right arrow Email this article to a friend
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Similar articles in Web of Science
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Add to Saved Citations
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Right arrowRequest Permissions
Right arrow Request Reprints
Right arrow Add to My Marked Citations
Citing Articles
Right arrow Citing Articles via HighWire
Right arrow Citing Articles via Web of Science (5)
Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Right arrow Citing Articles via Scopus
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by Mccrae, N.
Right arrow Search for Related Content
Social Bookmarking
Add to CiteULike   Add to Complore   Add to Connotea   Add to Del.icio.us   Add to Digg   Add to Reddit   Add to Technorati   Add to Twitter  
What's this?

‘A violent thunderstorm’: Cardiazol treatment in British mental hospitals

Niall Mccrae

Box P026, Health Services Research Department, Institute of Psychiatry, Denmark Hill, London SE5 8AF, UK. n.mccrae{at}iop.kcl.ac.uk

In the annals of psychiatric treatment, the advent of Cardiazol therapy has been afforded merely passing mention as a stepping-stone to the development of electroconvulsive therapy. Yet in the 1930s it was the most widely used of the major somatic treatment innovations in Britain's public mental hospitals, where its relative simplicity and safety gave it preference over the elaborate and hazardous insulin coma procedure. Devised on a dubious hypothesis of biological antagonism, Cardiazol armed psychiatry with an immediately effective weapon in the battle against schizophrenia, an enduring and debilitating condition responsible for over half of the mental hospital population. What made Cardiazol work – or appear to work? This account shows how evaluation of convulsive therapy was skewed by naÔve outcome measurement and diagnostic discrepancies, and how its therapeutic indication evolved from schizophrenia to affective disorders. Psychological mechanisms are considered, with the suggestion that the intense fear experienced during treatment – the major reason for abandoning Cardiazol in favour of electroshock – was therapeutically advantageous.

Key Words: Britain • Cardiazol treatment • convulsive therapy • electroshock • history • Isabel Wilson • Ladislaus von Meduna • Manfred Sakel • physical treatments • psychiatry

References

  • Abse, D. W. (1940) The psychology of convulsion therapy . Journal of Mental Science, 86, 95–99 .
  • Angyal, L. von and Gyárfás, K. (1936) ‘ber die Cardiazol-Krampfbehandlung der Schizophrenie. Archiv für Psychiatrie und Nervenkrankheiten, 106, 1–12.
  • Anonymous (1936) Needed reforms in psychiatry and neurology [editorial] . Journal of Neurology & Psychopathology, 17, 176–180 .
  • Anonymous (1968) Epilepsy and schizophrenia: relationship and biochemistry . Lancet, 291 (7539), 398–401 .[CrossRef]
  • Atkin, I. (1939) Triazol 156 in chronic schizophrenia . Lancet, 233 (6026), 435–437 .[CrossRef]
  • Bain, A. J. (1940) The influence of cardiazol on chronic schizophrenia . Journal of Mental Science, 86, 502–513 .
  • Barry, B. (1940) The use of cardiazol in psychiatry . Medical Journal of Australia, (16 Sept.), 430–437 .
  • Bellak, L. (1948) Dementia Praecox: The Past Decade's Work and Present Status: A Review and Evaluation( New York: Grune & Stratton ).
  • Bennett, A. E. (1940) Preventing traumatic complications in convulsive shock therapy by curare . Journal of the American Medical Association, 114, 322–324 .[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  • Beveridge, A. W. and Renvoise, E. B. (1988) Electricity: a history of its use in the treatment of mental illness in Britain during the second half of the 19th century . British Journal of Psychiatry, 153, 157–162 .[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  • Bexley Hospital (1937) Minutes of sub-committee meeting 7th July 1937.
  • Bierer, J. (1940) Psychotherapy in mental hospital practice . Journal of Mental Science, 86, 928–947 .
  • Bini, L. (1937) Richerche sperimentali nell'accesso epilettico da corrente elettrica . Schweizer Archiv für Neurologie und Psychiatrie, 39 (suppl.), 121–122 .
  • Blair, D. (1940) Prognosis in schizophrenia . Journal of Mental Science, 86, 378–473 .
  • Bleuler, E. (1911) Dementia Praecox oder die Gruppe der Schizophrenien. In G. Aschaffenburg (ed.), Handbook der Psychiatrie(Leipzig: Deuticke).
  • Board of Control for England & Wales (1938) The Twenty-fourth Annual Report of the Board of Control 1937( London: HMSO ).
  • Board of Control for England & Wales (1939) The Twenty-fifth Annual Report of the Board of Control 1938( London: HMSO ).
  • Braslow, J. (1997) Mental Ills and Bodily Cures: Psychiatric Treatment in the First Half of the Twentieth Century( Berkeley: University of California Press ).
  • Campbell Young, G. (1938) Convulsion therapy in schizophrenia (presented at The Royal Medico-Psychological Association Northern & Midland Division Autumn Meeting, October 27, 1937). Journal of Mental Science, 84 (suppl.), 8–9 .
  • Carse, J. (1946) Report of the medical superintendent. In Forty-Ninth Annual Report of Graylingwell Hospital( Chichester: John Crowther & Willis ).
  • Cerletti, U. (1954) Electroshock therapy . Journal of Clinical Experimental Psychopathology, 15, 191–217 .
  • Cohen, L. H. (1939) The therapeutic significance of fear in the Metrazol treatment of schizophrenia . American Journal of Psychiatry, 95, 1349–1357 .[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  • Cook, L. C. (1938a) Cardiazol convulsion therapy in schizophrenia . Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine, 31, 567–584 .
  • Cook, L. C. (1938b) The range of mental reaction states influenced by cardiazol convulsions . Journal of Mental Science, 84, 664–667 .
  • Cook, L. C. (1940) Has fear any therapeutic significance in convulsion therapy? Journal of Mental Science, 86, 484–490 .
  • Cook, L. C. (1944) Convulsion therapy . Journal of Mental Science, 90, 435–464 .
  • Cook, L. C. and Sands, D. E. (1941) Spinal injuries in convulsive therapy . Journal of Mental Science, 87, 230–240 .
  • Cooper, R. and Bird, J. (1989) The Burden: Fifty Years of Clinical and Experimental Neuroscience at the Burden Neurological Institute( Bristol: White Tree ).
  • Dax, E. C. (1940) Convulsion therapy by ammonium chloride . Journal of Mental Science, 86, 660–667 .
  • Dax, E. C. (1951) Indications for shock therapy . Journal of Mental Science, 97, 142–144 .
  • Dynes, J. B. (1939) Undesirable mental sequelae to convulsant drug therapy . Journal of Mental Science, 85, 493–497 .
  • Finiefs, L. A. (1937) Induced epileptiform attacks as a treatment of schizophrenia . Lancet, 231 (5979), 131-131 .[CrossRef]
  • Fleming, G. W. T. H., Golla, F. L. and Grey Walter, W. (1939) Electric-convulsion therapy of schizophrenia . Lancet, 234 (6070), 1353–1355 .[CrossRef]
  • Freudenberg, R. (1941) On the curability of mental diseases by ‘shock’ treatment . Journal of Mental Science, 87, 529–544 .
  • Gardner, J. (1999) Sweet Bells Jangled Out of Tune: A History of the Sussex Lunatic Asylum, Haywards Heath( Brighton: James Gardner ).
  • Gelder, M. (1991) Adolf Meyer and his influence on British psychiatry. In G. E. Berrios and H. Freeman (eds), 150 Years of British Psychiatry( London: Gaskell ), 419–435.
  • Georgi, F. (1937) Kramfproblem und Insulintherapie: Berücksichtigung klinischer und humoralpathologischer Gesichtpunkte. Schweizer Archiv für Neurologie und Psychiatrie, 39 (suppl.), 49–55.
  • Gillespie, J. E. O. N. (1939) Cardiazol convulsions: the subjective aspect . Lancet, 233 (6025), 391–392 .[CrossRef]
  • Gillies, I. H. L. (1937) Convulsive therapy in schizophrenia . Lancet, 231 (5979), 131–132 .
  • Good, R. (1940) Some observations on the psychological aspects of cardiazol therapy . Journal of Mental Science, 86, 491–501 .
  • Good, R. (1941) Convulsive therapy in war psychoneurotics . Journal of Mental Science, 87, 409–418 .
  • Harris, A. (1938) Cardiazol treatment of schizophrenia . Journal of Mental Science, 84, 735–775 .
  • Harris, J. S. and Birnie, C. R. (1938) Cardiazol therapy in stupor . British Medical Journal, 4051, 449–451 .
  • Hemphill, R. E. and Walter, W. G. (1941) The treatment of mental disorders by electrically induced convulsions . Journal of Mental Science, 87, 256–275 .
  • Henderson, D. K. and Gillespie, R. D. (1936) A Textbook of Psychiatry, 4th edn ( London: Oxford University Press ).
  • Horsley, J. S. (1940) Convulsion therapy of early mental illness in out-patient clinics . Medical Press & Circular, 102, 70–73 .
  • James, F. E. (1992) Insulin treatment in psychiatry . History of Psychiatry, 3, 221–235 .
  • James, G. W. B., Freudenberg, R. and Cannon, A. T. (1937) Insulin shock of schizophrenia . Lancet, 229 (5932), 1101–1104 .[CrossRef]
  • Kalinowsky, L. B., Hoch, P. H. and Lewis, N. D. C. (1946) Shock Treatments and Other Somatic Procedures in Psychiatry( New York: Grune & Stratton ).
  • Kennedy, A. (1937) Convulsion therapy in schizophrenia . Journal of Mental Science, 83, 1–20 .
  • Kennedy, A. (1940) The treatment of mental disorders by induced convulsions: a critical review . Journal of Neurology & Psychiatry, 3, 49–82 .
  • Kraus, G. and Viersma, H. J. (1940) Lesions of the spinal column resulting from convulsion therapy . Journal of Mental Science, 86, 76–83 .
  • Lewis, A. (1934) Melancholia: a historical review . Journal of Mental Science, 80, 1–42 .
  • Lewis, A. (2003) Aubrey Lewis's report on visits to psychiatric centres in Europe in 1937. In K. Angel, E. Jones and M. Neve (eds), European Psychiatry on the Eve of War: Aubrey Lewis, the Maudsley Hospital and the Rockefeller Foundation in the 1930s (Medical History, suppl. 22) ( London: Wellcome Trust Centre for the History of Medicine ), 64–147.
  • Low, A. A., Sonenthal, I., Blaurock, M., Kaplan, M. and Sherman, I. (1938) Metrazol shock treatment of the functional psychoses . Archives of Neurology & Psychiatry, 39, 717–736 .
  • Mayer-Gross, W. and Walk, A. (1938) Cyclohexyl-ethyl-triazol in the convulsion treatment of schizophrenia . Lancet, 231 (5989), 1324–1325 .[CrossRef]
  • McCowan, P. K. (1938) Report of the physician superintendent for 1937. In The Ninety-eighth Annual Report for 1937 of the Crichton Royal Institution, Dumfries(Dumfries).
  • McCulley, W. J. (1946) Report of the medical superintendent for the year 1945. In The Annual Report of the St Andrew's Hospital, Thorpe, Norwich, for the Year 1945 and Statement of Accounts for the Year Ending 31st March, 1946( Norwich: Roberts ).
  • Meduna, L. J. von (1934) ‘ber experimentelle Kampferepilepsie . Archiv für Psychiatrie, 102, 333–339 .[CrossRef]
  • Meduna, L. J. von (1935) Versuche über die biologische Beeinflussung des Aflaubes der Schizophrenie. Zeitschrift für die gesamte Neurologie und Psychiatrie, 152, 235–62.
  • Meduna, L. J. von (1937) Die Konvulsionstherapie der Schizophrenie(Halle: Carl Marhold).
  • Meduna, L. J. von and Rohny, B. (1939) Insulin and cardiazol treatment of schizophrenia . Lancet, 233 (6038), 1139–1142 .[CrossRef]
  • Musto, D. (1981) A historical perspective. In S. Bloch and P. Chodoff (eds), Psychiatric Ethics ( Oxford: Oxford University Press ).
  • Neustatter, W. L. and Freeman, H. (1939) The prevention of fear in cardiazol therapy by preliminary anaesthesia with cyclopropane or with nitrous oxide . Lancet, 234 (6064), 1071–1072 .[CrossRef]
  • Nightingale, G. S. (1938) Six months' experience with cardiazol therapy . Journal of Mental Science, 84, 581–588 .
  • Nightingale, G. S. (1969) Warley Hospital 1853–1969( Brentwood: Warley Hospital ).
  • Pakenham-Walsh, R. (1956) Triazol in schizophrenia [letter] . Lancet, 268 (6951), 1048-1048 .
  • Pines, M. (1991) The development of the psychodynamic movement. In G. E. Berrios and H. Freeman 150 Years of British Psychiatry( London: Gaskell ), 206–231.
  • Pollock, H. M. (1939) A statistical study of 1140 dementia praecox cases treated with metrazol . Psychiatric Quarterly, (July), 553–562 .
  • Pratt, D. (1948) Public Mental Hospitals in England: A Survey( Philadelphia: National Mental Health Foundation ).
  • Pullar-Strecker, H. (1938) A comparison of insulin and cardiazol convulsion therapies in the treatment of schizophrenia . Lancet, 231 (5972), 371–373 .[CrossRef]
  • Reitmann, F. (1939) Cardiazol therapy of schizophrenia: some statistical data . Lancet, 233 (6026), 439–440 .[CrossRef]
  • RMPA = Royal Medico-Psychological Association (1938) [ Discussion at annual meeting] . Journal of Mental Science, 84, 685–692 .
  • Rollin, H. R. (1990) Festina Lente: A Psychiatric Odyssey( London: British Medical Journal ).
  • Russell, L. W. (1938) Insulin and cardiazol: experiences of the combined method . Journal of Mental Science, 84, 672–676 .
  • Sands, D. E. (1939) Insulin premedication in convulsion therapy . Lancet, 234 (6048), 250–251 .[CrossRef]
  • Sargant, W. (1967) The Unquiet Mind( London: Heinemann ).
  • Sargant, W. and Slater, E. (1944) An Introduction to Physical Methods of Treatment in Psychiatry ( Edinburgh: E. & S. Livingstone ).
  • Sargant, W. and Slater, E. (1972) An Introduction to Physical Methods of Treatment in Psychiatry, 5th edn ( Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone ).
  • Schweizerische Gesellschaft für Psychiatrie (1937) Bericht über die wissenschaftlichen Verhandlugen auf der 89 Versammlung der Schweizerischen Gesellschaft für Psychiatrie in Münsingen b. Bern am 29–31 Mai 1937. Schweizer Archiv für Neurologie und Psychiatrie, 39 (suppl.), 1–240.
  • Scull, A. (1994) The historiography of somatic treatments in psychiatry . History of Psychiatry, 5, 1–12 .
  • Shipley, W. H. and McGregor, J. S. (1940) The clinical applications of electrically induced convulsions . Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine, 33, 267–274 .
  • Silbermann, I. (1940) The psychical experiences during the shocks in shock therapy . International Journal of Psycho-analysis, (April), 179–200 .
  • Skottowe, I. (1939) Shock therapy: a plea for proportion in psychiatry . Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine, 32, 843–852 .
  • Sneader, W. (1985) Drug Discovery: The Evolution of Modern Medicines( Chichester: Wiley ).
  • Stalker, H., Millar, W. M. and Jacobs, J. M. (1939) Remissions in schizophrenia: insulin and convulsion therapies compared with ordinary treatment . Lancet, 233 (6026), 437–438 .[CrossRef]
  • Strauss, E. B. and MacPhail, A. (1940) Treatment of out-patients by electrical convulsant therapy with a portable apparatus . British Medical Journal, 4170, 779–782 .
  • Ström-Olsen, R. (1945) Report of the physician superintendent for the year 1944. In The Eighth Annual Report of Runwell Hospital( County Boroughs of East Ham & Southend-on-Sea ).
  • Sullivan, H. S. (1940) Conceptions of modern psychiatry . Psychiatry, 3, 1–117 .
  • Thomas, J. S. (1940) Some clinical observations of ‘dys-symbole’: its relation to shock therapy . Journal of Mental Science, 86, 100–108 .
  • Thomas, R. W. and Wilson, I. G. H. (1938) Report on Cardiazol Treatment and on the Present Application of Hypoglycaemic Shock Treatment in Schizophrenia( London: Board of Control for England and Wales ).
  • Tooth, G. and Blackburn, J. M. (1939) Disturbance of memory after convulsion treatment . Lancet, 234 (6044), 17–20 .[CrossRef]
  • Valenstein, E. S. (1973) Brain Control: A Critical Examination of Brain Stimulation and Psychosurgery( New York: Wiley-Interscience ).
  • Valentine, R. (1996) Asylum, Hospital, Haven: A History of Horton Hospital( London: Riverside Mental Health Trust ).
  • Verstraeten P. (1937) SociÈtÈ de MÈdecine Mentale de Belgique: sÈance du 23 octobre 1937 . Annales MÈdicoPsychologiques, 95, 700-700 .
  • Wilson, I. G. H. (1936) A Study of Hypoglycaemic Shock Treatment in Schizophrenia( London: HMSO ).
  • Wilson, I. G. H. (1963) Travels in psychiatry . British Journal of Psychiatry, 109, 169–177 .
  • Wyllie, A. M. (1938) Treatment of mental disorders by cardiazol . Glasgow Medical Journal, 129, 269–279 .
  • Wyllie, A. M. (1940) Convulsion therapy of the psychoses . Journal of Mental Science, 86, 248–259 .

History of Psychiatry, Vol. 17, No. 1, 67-90 (2006)
DOI: 10.1177/0957154X06061723
Add to CiteULike CiteULike   Add to Complore Complore   Add to Connotea Connotea   Add to Del.icio.us Del.icio.us   Add to Digg Digg   Add to Reddit Reddit   Add to Technorati Technorati   Add to Twitter Twitter    What's this?


This article has been cited by other articles:


Home page
 Br. J. PsychiatryHome page
G. Gazdag, I. Bitter, G. S. Ungvari, and B. Baran
Convulsive therapy turns 75
The British Journal of Psychiatry, May 1, 2009; 194(5): 387 - 388.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

Home page
 Soc Hist MedHome page
E. Jones and S. Rahman
Framing Mental Illness, 1923-1939: The Maudsley Hospital and its Patients
Soc Hist Med, April 1, 2008; 21(1): 107 - 125.
[Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]

This Article
Right arrow Abstract Freely available
Right arrow Free Full Text (Free PDF) Free
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Right arrow Citation Map
Services
Right arrow Email this article to a friend
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Similar articles in Web of Science
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Add to Saved Citations
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Right arrowRequest Permissions
Right arrow Request Reprints
Right arrow Add to My Marked Citations
Citing Articles
Right arrow Citing Articles via HighWire
Right arrow Citing Articles via Web of Science (5)
Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Right arrow Citing Articles via Scopus
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by Mccrae, N.
Right arrow Search for Related Content
Social Bookmarking
Add to CiteULike   Add to Complore   Add to Connotea   Add to Del.icio.us   Add to Digg   Add to Reddit   Add to Technorati   Add to Twitter  
What's this?